Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (2024)

When it comes to cooking the biggest meal of the year, you can't go wrong with these boast-worthy recipes that have already been battle-tested by your fellow home cooks at their own Thanksgiving feasts. Each of these delectable options has earned 1,000 reviews (and often a whole lot more) on Allrecipes — making them the best of the best. Scroll through to take a look at our most popular Thanksgiving recipes.

01of 24

Perfect Turkey

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (1)

Allrecipes user Shelly White credits her friend from France for this "perfectly seasoned and juicy" version of the Thanksgiving centerpiece, fragrant with fresh thyme and white wine. "She never measures anything, so use your own judgment for vegetable amounts," Shelly writes. "I usually err on the side of more is better!'" No room in your fridge for a bucket to brine the bird? Allrecipes user redamber recommends you pop your turkey and brine into an oven bag, squeeze out the air, tie it shut, and chill it overnight in a well-iced cooler.

02of 24

Roasted Brussels Sprouts

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (2)

If you never imagined you'd eat a Brussels sprout willingly, Allrecipes user BAYSIDE used to agree — until she tried this simple recipe. "These yummy, salty, nutty, crunchy, caramelized Brussels sprouts were SO good. No bitterness whatsoever!" Her advice: Halve the sprouts to avoid "mushy middles" and cut away the "sprout" part to avoid bitter flavors.

03of 24

Cranberry Sauce

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (3)

Sometimes, keeping it simple is simply the best. With just four ingredients, this recipe comes together easily on the stove and can be made ahead for ease and to let the flavors meld. "This was the best cranberry sauce I have ever had!" writes Allrecipes user LEXI, JACK and COOKIE. "I used to just resort to canned because I never seemed to be able to make a 'good' cranberry sauce."

04of 24

Homemade Mac and Cheese

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (4)

"Very creamy and yummy," writes Allrecipes user Julie Olsen. "If you think your sauce is too runny before pouring it over the macaroni, it's not. I was very nervous that my sauce was not thick enough, but once I poured it over the macaroni and baked it, the dish turned out wonderful!"

05of 24

Sweet Potato Pie

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (5)

"People who have eaten sweet potato pie all their lives say this recipe is the best they've ever tasted," writes Allrecipes user SL, who has baked this dessert three Thanksgivings in a row. What puts SL's version of this popular holiday recipe over the top? She swaps evaporated milk for the standard and replaces half the white sugar with brown.

06of 24

Granny Kat's Pumpkin Roll

View Recipe

If you're a jelly roll novice, it's your lucky day. The comments below Granny Kat's masterpiece are a treasure trove of tips to ensure your efforts won't wind up a #PinterestFail. Key wisdom: use a bigger pan than you think you need and don't attempt to cram in every last bit of filling. You'll find the work is worth it. "I wish there were more stars available because I'd give this recipe ALL of them," writes Allrecipes user Christie. "My husband, who has something to say about EVERYTHING, said 'Well, I just can't find one thing that I'd improve about this.'"

  • The Easiest Pumpkin Desserts You'll Ever Make

07of 24

Slow Cooker Turkey Breast

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (7)

We know what you're thinking: would anyone really fix the centerpiece of Thanksgiving dinner in a slow cooker? The answer is definitely yes. "I was skeptical about cooking turkey in the crock pot but was pleasantly surprised that it came out so moist," writes Lori, who also notes clean-up is easy. Plus, just think of all the extra oven space you've created to bake more pies!

08of 24

Cream Corn Like No Other

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (8)

Sure, you can always eat creamed corn from a can. But Allrecipes user LINDA MCLEAN writes that even her husband and youngest daughter couldn't believe the difference after tasting this recipe. "My older daughter can't stand creamed corn but decided to give this a taste. Guess what? Her plate had a huge helping!"

  • 36 Thanksgiving Corn Recipes From Traditional to New Classics

09of 24

Awesome Sausage, Apple, and Cranberry Stuffing

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (9)

"This is my favorite recipe on this site," writes Allrecipes user StephanieM. After just a few years of serving this stuffing, "it's demanded of me at every family get-together." She advises you to experiment with different types of bread until you find your favorite combo (she recommends sourdough and potato bread). And if you have them handy, reach for fresh herbs over dried for best results.

10of 24

Garlic Mashed Potatoes Secret Recipe

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (10)

Whether you're fixing mashed potatoes for your entire clan or a party of five, Allrecipes user AUSTAD's recipe offers garlicky joy. For a less intense but still enjoyable garlic-ness, heed the wisdom of fellow cook Z and use roasted garlic rather than raw.

11of 24

Yummy Sweet Potato Casserole

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (11)

"My family begs me to make this creamy baked dish every Thanksgiving and Christmas," writes Allrecipes user TinaB. "What makes it so good is the pecan topping! Try it, and I'm sure it will become your new tradition!"

12of 24

Grandma's Green Bean Casserole

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (12)

The key to rocking this recipe: fresh, steamed green beans, writes Allrecipes user momma_s. "I am not too big on veggies, but I CRAVE this dish!" For that familiar consistency, fellow Allrecipes user KIMAR recommends sautéeing the onion in butter until translucent, reducing the salt and flour by half, and adding half the cheese into the beans mixture.

13of 24

Apple Pie by Grandma Ople

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (13)

With 10,000+ reviews, this prize-winning recipe from the grandmother of MOSHASMAMA is a gift that keeps on giving and a highlight of holiday meals. The stand-out ingredient? Pleasingly tart Granny Smith apples. Review after review sings the praises of this straightforward pie. "Henceforth, I am eschewing all other apple pie recipes," writes wee red. "Truly spectacular."

14of 24

Winter Fruit Salad with Lemon Poppyseed Dressing

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (14)

If you're running out of time to concoct the dressing for this fresh and flavorful salad, substitute your favorite store-bought poppyseed dressing. Many reviewers also changed up the nuts or cheese to suit their personal tastes. "One word of caution," writes Allrecipes user KOALAGIRL. "This fed three hungry adults (two helpings for the men). So don't be fooled by the 'serves 12.' Your family and guests will go back for seconds, trust me!"

15of 24

Grandmother's Buttermilk Cornbread

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (15)

When in doubt, trust Grandma. This recipe from the grandmother of Allrecipes user BETHANYWEATHERSBY turns out reliably moist and tender. It also calls for sugar, as a heads up for those on the savory side of the great "should sugar exist in cornbread" debate. The correct answer: it depends on how your own grandma makes it!

16of 24

Downeast Maine Pumpkin Bread

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (16)

If you're looking for a treat other than pie this Thanksgiving, try this spicy pumpkin bread. Recipe creator Laurie Bennett says this bread is even better the day after it's baked, so you can make it ahead of time and have one less thing in your oven on Thanksgiving. "I cannot believe how delicious this recipe was! I have never tasted such a rich, soft, and filled-with-flavor pumpkin bread in my life," says reviewer Kenna Pomeroy.

17of 24

Sweet Dinner Rolls

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (17)

These are the soft, pillowy Thanksgiving dinner rolls you remember. Don't have a bread machine handy? Follow the lead of Allrecipes users K PRAPER and summer_lover for tips to get your dough rising on the stovetop and countertop.

18of 24

Butternut Squash Soup

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (18)

Smooth, creamy, decadent … and yes, we're talking about soup, people! Make this ahead and freeze to have one less task to tackle on turkey day. To save even more time, skip the hassle of hacking apart a raw squash and make it like Allrecipes user JINGSHI: "The easiest way to prepare butternut squash is to pierce it with a fork and bake it, whole, at 400 degrees F for one hour. Let cool, then halve lengthwise and remove the seeds. The flesh scoops out easily with a spoon. No cutting or dicing required." Save even more time by buying pre-diced, frozen butternut squash.

19of 24

Double Layer Pumpkin Cheesecake

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (19)

Warning: this cheesecake is so good it may very well walk right away from you. So cautions Allrecipes user bonniejo roberts, who took it to work, went to answer the phone, came back 10 minutes later, "and the whole cheesecake was gone! I couldn't believe it!" The moral of this story: let the call go to voicemail.

20of 24

Mouth-Watering Stuffed Mushrooms

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (20)

This is the perfect recipe to delegate to one of your guests who really wants to make something simple but impressive. Take them to the next level with these tips from Allrecipes user (and repeat stuffed mushroom-making master) Stephanie G.: add crabmeat to the mixture to boost the savory quotient, use smaller mushrooms to create a better balance between mushroom and filling, sprinkle with Parmesan cheese just before baking, and bake them in mini muffin tin pans to keep the mushrooms from tipping over and rolling around in the oven.

21of 24

White Chocolate and Cranberry Cookies

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (21)

Allrecipes user Carla Brown recommends doubling this recipe and adding ½ cup of chopped pecans. Fellow baker LongIslandBorn echoed many other reviewers with her advice to swap vanilla extract for the brandy: "What can I say? I've now found a family tradition that I will make for Thanksgiving and Christmas forever!"

22of 24

Awesome and Easy Creamy Corn Casserole

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (22)

This slightly sweet and extra creamy corn casserole only requires a few ingredients but will be a hit at Thanksgiving dinner. It's easy to throw together, and if you double the ingredients, you can make the casserole in a 9x13-inch baking dish. "I've made this casserole for Thanksgiving the last two years. There is never a crumb left! Everyone loves it," says home cook IRISHMAIDEN.

23of 24

Brown Family's Favorite Pumpkin Pie

View Recipe

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (23)

What makes this pumpkin pie a real winner? The walnut streusel topping. "There aren't enough stars for this pumpkin pie! Everyone raved about it! The streusel topping is incredible, and the pie itself makes a great presentation," says reviewer Jillian.

  • Does Pumpkin Pie Need to Be Refrigerated?

24of 24

More Inspiration

Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (24)

  • 24 of Grandma's Best Thanksgiving Recipes
  • Our 25 Best New Thanksgiving Recipes for 2021
  • More Thanksgiving Recipes
Our Top Thanksgiving Recipes with 1,000+ Reviews (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Aracelis Kilback

Last Updated:

Views: 6643

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (44 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Aracelis Kilback

Birthday: 1994-11-22

Address: Apt. 895 30151 Green Plain, Lake Mariela, RI 98141

Phone: +5992291857476

Job: Legal Officer

Hobby: LARPing, role-playing games, Slacklining, Reading, Inline skating, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Dance

Introduction: My name is Aracelis Kilback, I am a nice, gentle, agreeable, joyous, attractive, combative, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.